Talk to Priest Maxi sitting on a bench west of the town hall.
Head back to the church and find Jesus hiding behind the seats. Return to the priest and talk to him.
He'll ask you to find Jesus one more time. Return to the church and turn off the lights using the switch to the right. Next, point both lamps toward the cross to reveal Jesus' shadow. Find him behind the pulpit.
Reward:
- New Friend Requests: Priest Maxi, Jesus
- Summon Unlocked: Rosary